Organ Transplantation in Suspicious Death Case Forensic Medical and Ethical Issues
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17986/blm.2011161722Keywords:
forensic medicine, organ transplantation, autopsyAbstract
Even if the developments in medical technology provide a second chance to the patients without any hope to live with organ transplantation, it has also resulted with the initiation of endless legal and ethical discussions. In this study, we aimed to discuss the legal and ethical issues rising from the transplantation of the organs collected from the donors whose brain death occured due to a suspicious condition. In this study, we have reviewed a case in which the organ transplantation process has been initiated following brain death occured after a suspicious condition reported as legal case to the Regulatory Authorities and to our department for the request of expert opinion. The current legal regulations, applications and the controversies inbetween were discussed. The brain death of a 2.5 year old female patient who had been found unconscious and transferred to the University Hospital's Intensive Care Unit was occured despite of all interventions after 8 days. During this period the reason of death could not be revealed and the case was reported to the legal authorities. Simultaneously the organ transplantation process was initiated and the Public Prosecutor was acknowledged. The forensic medicine specialists have been forced to decide between the legal responsibilities and the highest health interest and benefits. After the review of the medical documents, it was decided that the removal of the organs which were planned to be used in transplantation would not be effecting the results of the autopsy. The operation was done by the transplantation team and the liver and both kidneys were removed. The heart was left due to a possible cardiac disease. The autopsy was performed under these circumstances and the necessary samples were collected. The obligation of the autopsy for the determination of the reason of death, the necessity of the investigation of the organs removed for transplantation in order to understand the possible cause of death, the limitation of the time, the obtaining of the informed consent from the family were the medical and legal issues have to be adressed. Although the legal regulations associated with the organ transplantation maintain the compliance of the process to criminal law and solve the problems of reponsibility, this miraculous opportunity resulting from the organ transplantation offered by the developments in medicine and technology, was restricted by the conflict between regulations and principles of highest health interest and benefits. As a result all the parties involved were left in a difficult moral and legal situation.
Key words: Forensic medicine, organ transplantation, autopsy.
Downloads
References
Demirhan EA. Organ aktarmaları. Tıbbi Deontoloji ve Genel Tıp Tarihi (2. Baskı). Bursa, Güneş ve Nobel Yayınlan, 1996;9-117.
Edime T. Türkiye'de organ ve doku nakli uygulamalan: Sonuçlan ve strateji önerileri. Türkiye Klinikleri J Med Sei 2004;24:261-6.
Naçar M, Çetinkaya F, Kanyılmaz D, Tokgöz B, Utaş C. Hekim adaylarının organ nakline bakış açılan. Türk Nefroloji Diyaliz ve Transplantasyon Dergisi 2001;10:123-8.
Özdağ N. Organ nakli ve bağışma toplumun bakışı. C. Ü. Hemşirelik Yüksekokulu Dergisi 2001 ;5:46-55.
Woo KT. Social and cultural aspects of organ donotion in Asia. Ann Acad Med Singapore 1992;21:421 -7.
Organ ve Doku Alınması, Saklanması ve Nakli Hakkında Kanun. 3.6.1979 gün ve 16655 sayılı Resmi Gazete.
Gökçen A. Organ ve doku nakli üzerine düşünceler. Selçuk Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi Milenyum Armağanı, 2000;8;63-85.
Organ ve Doku Nakli Hizmetleri Yönetmeliği, 01.06.2000 gün ve 24066 sayılı Resmi Gazete.
Akıncı Ş. Türk Özel Hukuku'nda Cesetten Yapılan Organ Nakilleri ve Bu Konuda Gerçekleştirilmesi Düşünülen Yeni Düzenlemeler, Prof. Dr. Halil Çin'e 10. Yıl Hizmet Armağanı, Selçuk Üniversitesi, Konya 1995; 429-447.
Atamer Y. M. Ölüden Organ Naklinin Beraberinde Getirdiği Bazı Hukuki Soranlar, Milletlerarası Hukuk Bülteni 1999-2000;125-155.
Akıncı Ş. Türk Özel Hukuku'nda Cesetten Yapılan Organ Nakilleri ve Bu Konuda Gerçekleştirilmesi Düşünülen Yeni Düzenlemeler, Prof. Dr. Halil Çin'e 10. Yıl Hizmet Armağanı, Selçuk Üniversitesi, Konya 1995; 432-433.
Biyoloji ve Tıbbın Uygulanması Bakımından İnsan Haklan ve İnsan Haysiyetinin Korunması Sözleşmesi: İnsan Hakları Ve Biyotıp Sözleşmesinin Onaylanmasının Uygun Bulunduğuna Dair Kanun. Kanun No:5013,ResmiGazete: 09.12.2003-25311
Artuk M.E, Gökçen A. Yenidünya C. Ceza Hukuku Genel Hükümler I, Ankara 2002;485.
Adli Vakalar ve Organ Nakli, 05.03.2007. http://www.turkhukuksitesi. com/showthread.php?t = 12 862 (Erişim tarihi: 10.11.2011).
Garson Jr A, Dick II M, Fournier A, et al. The long QT syndrome in children, an international study of 287 patients. Circulation 1993;87:1866-72. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.87.6.1866
SilkaMJ. Sudden Cardiac Death. In: Moss and Adams' Heart Disease in Infants, Children, and Adolescent, (6th Edition, Volume 1 ) (Eds: Ailen HD, Gutgesell HP, Clark EB, Driscoll DJ), Lippincott Williams&Wilkins, 2001:543-4.
Gillette PC, Garson Jr A, Case CL, Kanter RJ, Winslow AT. Management of arrhythmias. In: Paediatric Cardiology, Volume One, 2nd Edition (Eds: Anderson RH, Baker EJ, Macartney FJ, Rigby ML, Shineboume EA, Tynan M), ChurchillLivingstone, 2002:753.
Vincent GM: Long QT syndrome. Cardiology Clinics 2000;18:309-25 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0733-8651(05)70143-0
Weintraub RG, Gow RM. The congenital long QT syndrome in childhood. J Am Coll Cardiol 1990:674- 80. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0735-1097(90)90359-W
Schwartz PJ: Idiopathic long QT syndrome: progress and questions. Am Heart J1985;lll;399-411. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0002-8703(85)90626-X
Schwartz PJ, Moss AJ, Vincent GM, Crampton RS: Diagnostic criteria for the long QT syndrome: an update. Circulation 1993;88:782-4. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.88.2.782
Bozoklar A. Türkiye'de organ bağışı; 2008: Koordinatör perspektifi, Türkiye Klinikleri J Gen Surg- Special Topics Perspektifi 2009;2(1):5-9
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The Journal and content of this website is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) License. The Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY) allows users to copy, distribute and transmit an article, adapt the article and make commercial use of the article. The CC BY license permits commercial and non-commercial re-use of an open access article, as long as the author is properly attributed.
